Why Handymen Should Never Pay for Leads

Direct answer: Ray Duke tells handymen never to buy leads from sites like Angi (Angie's List) and Thumbtack. The same lead gets sold to several handymen, you pay a big slice of the job just for a chance to bid, and that cost ends up in your price. There are not enough handymen to go around, so you can find your own clients for free or for less.
Below: why Ray is against it, in his words, and the alternatives from his list, grouped so you can pick where to start.
- 51 ways to get work Ray lists that aren't buying leads
- 3-5 other handymen sold the same lead, by Ray's account
- 20% of a $125 job gone to a $25 lead in Ray's example
Why Ray says stop paying for leads
Ray also points out that the site makes about as much from catching and reselling the client as the handyman makes doing the job, and then spends that money staying between you and your next client.
This is my most passionate topic and pillar number 10 is don't pay for leads. I need you guys to stop paying for leads. It's really bad for this industry.
They're now getting between you and the client and saying, no, no, no, you got to pay the toll. If you want to get to the client, you got to pay the toll and I'm the toll keeper. So you pay them that toll just for the privilege of talking to that client. And then, by the way, they also sell that same client to three or four or five other providers.
- They sit between you and the client: Lead sites spend heavily to catch homeowners first and convince them the only safe way to hire is through the site.
- The same lead, sold again: You aren't buying a customer. You're buying a chance, and three to five other handymen paid for the same one.
- The math: Ray's example: a $25 faucet lead on a $125 job is 20% gone before you start, and five other handymen paid that same 20%.
- Your client pays for it: That lead fee gets built into your price. Without it you could charge less and win more work, or keep the full amount.
You don't need them
Ray's reason you can skip lead sites: demand is bigger than supply. Your job is to find good clients, vet them, impress them and let reviews and referrals build.
Do not buy leads. You guys don't need to buy leads. There are not enough handymen. There are not enough electricians. There are not enough plumbers. Not enough landscapers.
What you need to do is you need to find great clients. You need to find the clients. You need to vet the clients. You need to impress the clients, get more reviews, get more recommendations and referrals, and start building that client base. But paying for leads is never a good idea.
You will have a lot of guys who will tell you actually paying for leads is okay in the beginning because you're paying for those leads and those leads become your good clients. I guess so, but you don't need to pay for leads to find those good clients.
What to do instead: free online basics
- Google Business Profile + reviews: Ray's number one. Free to set up; the more reviews, the higher you rank. See the step-by-step guide linked below.
- A website: Easy and affordable. Build it yourself with an AI builder like Wix, or hire a company.
- Business social media: TikTok, Facebook, Instagram, YouTube. Post your work and put your city in titles and descriptions so locals find you.
- Yelp: Free to claim your business and answer comments. There is a paid version; Ray doesn't know if it works.
- Better Business Bureau: Older clients check the BBB to see your reputation.
- Nextdoor: Ray's understanding: Nextdoor doesn't charge the business for leads. You can also pay for ads there.
What to do instead: business clients (Ray's favorite)
Ray's entire business is built on property management companies. Business clients send repeat work, so one good one beats a pile of single leads.
- Property management companies: An endless supply of work they're legally required to get done. They need reliable handymen who can juggle many jobs at once.
- Realtors: They need handymen all the time. Ray prefers seller's agents: more motivated, and willing to pay a premium.
- Small local businesses: Many handle their own maintenance even in leased spaces.
- Other trades: Plumbing companies, restoration companies and new-home builders send off the small touch-up and finish jobs.
- HOAs: Get into their newsletters and onto their preferred vendor lists.
- Moving companies: People moving in or out almost always need something fixed or mounted.
- Insurance work: Managed repair networks (TPAs) and local insurance adjusters need handymen for touch-up work. Ray says insurance work pays really well.
- Government and institutional bids: Cities, counties, states, universities and the Department of Defense. Get accepted into their vendor portal, then bid. Some contracts are big.
What to do instead: get your name in front of people
- Vehicle wraps or magnets: Your business name and phone number on your vehicle bring phone calls.
- Business cards: Have them, pass them out, and ask everybody to pass them out for you.
- Bulletin boards: Ace Hardware, Home Depot, grocery stores, schools, convenience stores.
- Yard signs: Cheap signs on street corners. Check your local rules first.
- Apparel and branded gifts: Hats, shirts and jackets with your brand and phone number; cheap pens, flashlights or pocket knives with your name on them.
- Home shows and events: A booth at your city's home show, or a sponsor sign at the local ball field.
- Local print: Local newspapers and classifieds, and the coupon books local high school teams sell door to door.
- Paid ads you run yourself: Facebook and Instagram ads, Google pay-per-click, mass mailers, door hangers, local radio or TV, billboards, local influencers, Groupon. Ray lists these as options; they are ads, not bought leads.
What to do instead: people who already know you
So the goal shouldn't be to maximize the amount of Revenue that you can spend on advertising and acquiring new clients. The goal should be to make ... your existing clients as happy as possible and maximize the value again that you give them and that they give you.
- Your existing clients: Keep them happy and in touch: fridge magnets, holiday cards, an email to your own client list with seasonal specials.
- Referral program: Reward clients who send friends your way. Jobber has one built in.
- Upsell on the job: Fixing a running toilet and see rotten fascia on the way in? Offer an estimate.
- Friends and family: Have your family post on their own Facebook pages that they know a handyman.
- Networking: Chamber of commerce, realtors associations, and community service, where local business owners meet.
- Door to door: Knock and offer your services. Ray says you'd be surprised how many people need a handyman now.
- Craigslist: A five or six dollar ad. Ray says that's a lot of how he got his start.
Watch out: these are close to buying leads
Some options on Ray's list come with his own warnings. Know what you're signing up for.
- Google Local Services Ads: Pay per contact, not a resold lead, but Ray says: 'I do not recommend.'
- Home Depot referral program: You trade the points you earn shopping there for leads. Handymen tell Ray they like it; he still doesn't like trading value for a lead.
- Amazon Home Services: They take a percentage of the job. Still a middleman, but at least you pay for a real job, not a shared lead.
- TaskRabbit: Doesn't charge for leads, but it doesn't pay well because of cheap competition.
- Facebook community groups: When someone asks for a handyman, a dozen people offer a cousin who works for $12 an hour.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is it okay to buy leads just in the beginning?
Ray hears that a lot. His answer: you don't need to pay for leads to find good clients. There aren't enough handymen, so find, vet and impress your own clients instead.
What's wrong with Angi and Thumbtack leads?
Ray's view: they put themselves between you and the client, charge you a toll to talk to them, and sell the same lead to three to five other providers. The fee ends up in your price.
Are Google Local Services Ads the same as buying leads?
Not exactly. Ray says they charge per contact and don't resell your lead to others, but it is still pay-per-lead and he doesn't recommend it.
Where should I start if I can't pay for leads?
Ray's number one is a free Google Business Profile with reviews. His personal favorite, and his whole business, is property management companies, which you can land in person.